Finally found a copy of Alice: Madness Returns so I can play the original Alice from the game menu! The game is free for anyone with a copy of Alice Madness Returns. :
Replacement Case ONLY for ALICE MADNESS RETURNS PLAYSTATION 3 PS3 - | eBay
Alice: Madness Returns [EA Best Hits Version] for PlayStation 3
Amazon.com: Alice: Madness Returns - Playstation 3 : Everything Else
Alice: Madness Returns PS3 PlayStation3 JAPAN ver【ship from USA】 | eBay